The Toyota Prius Prime has beat out the newest EVs for the title of greenest automotive. Regardless of extra EVs coming to market, not one of the newest fully-electric autos within the U.S. managed to outdo the effectivity of the common-or-garden Prius plug-in, based on the Washing Submit and up to date findings within the 2024 GreenerCars report.

The Prius Prime has held on to its title because the greenest automotive for years because of its small measurement and low weight, which trendy EVs eschew for the sake of higher vary and pointless options that not solely enhance their costs, however, extra importantly, inflate their measurement and weight. It doesn’t matter how inexperienced your EV is that if it’s powered by a huge battery, which prices valuable assets and would go unused by most People whose each day distance necessities are available in at a mean of 27 miles. From the Washington Submit:

…a brand new report from the American Council for an Vitality Environment friendly Economic system means that the “greenest” automotive in America is probably not absolutely electrical. The nonprofit group, which has rated the air pollution from autos for many years, says the profitable automotive this 12 months is the Toyota Prius Prime SE, a plug-in hybrid that may go 44 miles on electrical energy earlier than switching to hybrid.

“It’s the form of the physique, the know-how inside it, and the general weight,” mentioned Peter Huether, senior analysis affiliate for transportation at ACEEE. “And all various kinds of Priuses are very environment friendly.”

[…]

The evaluation reveals that merely working on electrical energy will not be sufficient to ensure {that a} automotive is “inexperienced” — its weight, battery measurement and total effectivity matter, too. Whereas a big electrical truck weighing hundreds of kilos is perhaps higher than a gasoline truck of the identical measurement, each can be outmatched by a smaller, environment friendly gasoline automobile. And the extra large autos there are on the highway, the more durable it is going to be for the US to fulfill its objective of zeroing out emissions by 2050.

The GreenerCars report analyzes 1,200 vehicles accessible in 2024, assessing each the carbon dioxide emissions of the automobile whereas it’s on the highway and the emissions of producing the automotive and battery. It additionally assesses the influence of pollution past carbon dioxide, together with nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide and particulate matter — all of which may hurt human well being.

Of the 1,200 autos examined within the GreenerCar report, the Prius Prime PHEV got here in with the best rating of 71 factors out of a doable 100. The report assigns a “inexperienced rating” by taking into consideration CO2 emitted by the manufacture of a given automobile in addition to its emissions when used on the highway. The Prius Prime blew many new EVs out of the water, together with the GMC Hummer EV, which got here in with a rating of 29 factors.

The Hummer EV bought an abysmal rating because of its measurement and weight of over 9,000 kilos, which is due largely to an unlimited battery. After all, the halo EV from GMC options a number of the most superior off-road tech ever seen on a manufacturing automobile. However for what, precisely? Maybe to justify its excessive value. The Hummer EV is perhaps a powerful machine, however a inexperienced one it isn’t. And its foremost conceit as an eco-friendly automobile is fully misplaced because of its extra.

The small, environment friendly Prius Prime has a battery that’s lower than one-tenth the dimensions of the Hummer EV’s battery, based on the Washington Submit. Not solely is the manufacture of the Prius Prime much less resource-intense, however its use produces much less carbon emissions over its doable lifetime relative to the Hummer EV.

In actual fact, the Hummer fared so poorly, it was among the many lowest-ranking autos on the checklist, together with the Ram 1500 TRX and Ford F-150 Raptor R, which had inexperienced scores of twenty-two and 24, respectively. In the meantime, the Prius Prime beat EVs just like the Nissan Leaf and Kia EV6, which ranked on the high of the examine with scores within the 60s. And this occurs to be the third time the Prius Prime will get the highest spot, having beforehand executed so in 2020 and 2022.

One caveat within the examine is the ACEEE assumes Prius Prime house owners had been utilizing its all-electric vary for a “little over 50 % of their driving.” One professional disagrees with the findings, because the WaPo experiences, saying real-world use may undercut the information. However, then once more, Prius Prime house owners may drive their vehicles counting on its all-electric vary greater than the examine assumes. Both approach, the examine means that the greenest EV is definitely the smallest and lightest one.